Direct Nutrient-Feeding to 'Ney Poovan' Banana (Musa Sp. AB) Bunch under Organic or Conventional Farming for Yield, Fruit Quality and Profitability

S. C. Kotur


Three types of direct nutrient-feeding methods [applying 500g fresh cow-dung and 100ml water enriched with (i) 2.5g each of urea + SOP; (ii) 100ml of panchangavya; and (iii) 100ml of cow urine] were evaluated in 'Ney Poovan' banana grown under organic or conventional farming. Plants grown under conventional farming were more robust in girth and length of their pseudostem and number of leaves retained on the plant at harvest. Conventional farming produced 62.6% and 59.0% higher fruit and bunch weight than plants grown under organic farming. Quality-wise, fruits from organic farming were superior in pulp:peel ratio and pulp total soluble solids (TSS). Conventional farming significantly increased P, S, Fe, Mn and Zn content of the pulp over organic farming. Benefit:cost ratio was significantly higher at 3.61 under conventional farming, while, it was 2.15 under organic farming. All the methods of direct nutrient-feeding of banana bunch tested were significantly superior to 'Control' where the male bud was retained on the bunch until harvest. Increase in fruit and bunch weight was in the following order of blend: urea + SOP > panchangavya > cow urine, with fresh cow dung. Improvement in pulp:peel ratio and benefit:cost ratio was maximum when direct nutrient-feeding was done using cow-dung blended with urea + SOP, while, TSS of the pulp declined to 24.0oB from 25.1oB when pancahgavya was used. Results indicated that conventional farming with adequate organic manuring, and, adopting direct nutrient-feeding of the banana bunch using cow-dung slurry enriched with 2.5g each of urea and SOP, achieved high bunch yield, pulp:peel ratio, and was profitable.


Bunch Size, Direct Nutrient-Feeding, ‘Ney Poovan’ Banana, Musa Sp. AB, Organic Farming, Conventional Farming, Fruit Quality, Benefit:Cost Ratio

Full Text:



Ancy, T.K., Kurien, S., Augustin, A. and Balachandran, P.V. 1998. Urease activity in banana fruit. J. Pl. Nut., 21:2127-2140

Ancy, T.K. and Kurien, S. 2000. Bunch-stalk feeding of urea in banana Musa (AAB group) ‘Nendran’. Sci. Hort., 84:205-212

Kotur, S.C. and Keshava Murthy, S.V. 2008. Enhancing the fruit yield of ‘Robusta’ banana (Musa×paradisiaca L.) by de-navelling and feeding nitrogen, potassium and sulphur through the distal-end of the bunch. Indian J. Agril. Sci., 78:109-115

Kotur, S.C. and Keshava Murthy, S.V. 2010. Enhancing fruit yield in ‘Ney Poovan’ banana (Musa paradisiaca L.) by de-navelling and feeding N, K and S through distal stalk-end of the bunch. J. Hort. Sci., 5:53-56

Prasanna Kumari Amma, S., Babylatha, A.K., Pushkaran, K. and Kurien, T.K. 1986. Studies on the effect of removing terminal hands and male bud on the yield and fruit size of banana Musa (AAB group) ‘Palayankodan’. South Indian Hort., 34:204-209

Singh, H.P. 2001. Banana. In: Handbook of Horticulture, Chadha, K.L. (Ed.) p. 152, Indian Council of Agricultural Research, New Delhi

Venkatarayappa, T., Narasham, B. and Venkatesan, C. 1976. Effect of post-shooting application of urea on development and composition of banana fruit. South Indian Hort., 19:109-117

Copyright (c) 2016 Journal of Horticultural Science